There is no question that solid stain is the absolute bane of everything we believe in at Sand & Stain. Our promise to you is captured right in our original tagline: ‘Never Peel Again’—and if there’s one thing we’re certain of, it’s that solid stain will peel in Canada, no matter who applies it.

Probably the biggest reason solid stain fails, is because it acts much like a paint opposed to a stain. Paint protects by forming an outer film coating and is built up with layers and is far too thick to ever penetrate the wood. That’s why when you see solid stains or paint on exterior wood like a deck or fence, it peels off in pieces / chunks and leaves completely bare wood behind.

I’m surprised solid stain is even classified as a stain—it really should be called a paint, because it basically is no different than a can of flat sheen exterior water based paint. Sometimes people ask why we don’t restore decks, fence, and siding projects with solid stain and paint anymore, and there are many reasons for that:

Prospective clients often ask me if water based stains are better than oil based stains, or what will last the longest between transparent / semi-transparent / solid stains, or if newer age technology hybrid stains are the way to go.

I always answer that question with another question…

Do you want a peeling problem or a fading problem?

The truth is, it doesn’t matter if they hire me, my competition or do it themselves. The result is the same: either the deck will peel or the deck will fade.

When it comes to wood decks like cedar or pressure treated, there is no such thing as ‘zero maintenance’ unless you want your wood becoming increasingly gray and dirty over time.

The closest thing to maintenance free wood is charclad, Japanese style charred wood building materials and decor from our sister company.

Even after a short time reading our articles, (not to mention the dead giveaway from our tagline, Never Peel Again), you would know that our philosophy fully endorses a fading strategy versus peeling.

Since day one, literally every single business decision and recommendation we make is to ensure your deck will never peel.

You can check out our 3 part Sand & Stain System here, or continue reading about the difference between water based and oil based stain.

Before we get into why one coat is better than two to both protect your deck and prevent it from peeling, we need to go over a few assumptions about your deck, types of stain, and prep. If your deck consistently peels every year, no matter what you do, read our previous post, Why Your Deck Peels Every Year, for reasons about why that might be the case.

So, you invested good money into your brand new deck, or bought a house that came with a gorgeous deck in the backyard. You want to protect that investment as best you can, so the first inclination is to put as many protective layers on that wood as you can—’the more the better!’, you think to yourself.

Unfortunately, too much product is one of the surest ways to end up with a peeling deck—especially if it’s a thicker, water based formula.

This article is far more than a product comparison. We at Sand & Stain have been using the Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck Transparent Penetrating Oil as the main product in our business for over 10 years. It’s a huge part of the reason we have been able to keep our #1 promise to our clients (also our slogan): Never Peel Again.

Suffice it to say, it came as a shock in the summer of 2020 that this exceptional product was reformulated without so much as a notice or warning. Not even the local Sherwin-Williams store managers knew this was being rolled out (at least not in any of my local Ontario or Quebec stores.) Staff simply re-ordered more product as normal, and in came the new SuperDeck. Aside from a brown strip on the bottom of the can and slightly difference literature (left vs right in pic below), it’s practically an unnoticeable difference.

Until you open the can…